RARGOM Annual
Science Meeting, Portsmouth, NH Oct 6, 2010
Presentations
Public Beliefs About
Climate Change in the Gulf
of Maine
Region
Lawrence Hamilton, University of New Hampshire, Durham, NH
Do
scientists agree about climate change?
What do you personally believe?
We recently began exploring these questions through statewide
public-opinion surveys in New Hampshire, and others conducted in
coastal regions of Maine and elsewhere. Large majorities of the New Hampshire and Maine respondents know that
climate is changing now, although many attribute this to natural causes. Belief in natural vs. anthropogenic causes
varies with age, education and political leanings. Age, education and politics also affect
perceptions about the scientific consensus; people tend to believe that science
supports their personal opinion. The
sharp partisan divisions regarding climate change might also affect views on
local and coastal environmental issues.
Can changes in silver hake off the
Northeast coast of the US
and Canada
and Gulf
of Maine
be related to and predicted by the strength of the Atlantic Thermohaline
Circulation?
Terrence
M. Joyce, Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution, Woods Hole, MA
Working
with Colleagues at WHOI (Young-Oh Kwon) and at NMFS (Janet Nye), we have been
examining changes in biomass and location of silver hake using over 40 years of
annual assessment data. Large interannual changes
have been measured in biomass in the Gulf of Maine and north/south
location of silver hake on the shelf and continental slope. We find that these
changes are well-correlated with an index of the Gulf Stream (GS) path. In
years of a more northerly GS path, the Slope Water temperatures are warmer and
the silver hake aggregate further to the north and in the Gulf of Maine. The opposite is found
in years of a more southerly GS. We will show the connection between GS path
and strength of the Atlantic Thermohaline Circulation, as well as comment on
the relationship of interannual changes and long-term
trends in GS path and silver hake that suggest that changes in GS path precede and therefore might predict changes
in silver hake. Some preliminary results for other
commercially-important fish stocks are also presented and prospects for very long-term,
climate-related changes discussed.
The impact of climate variability and
change on ecosystem productivity across trophic levels
Charles
Stock, NOAA Geophysical Fluid Dynamics Laboratory
Uncertainty
in projections of the impact of climate change on fisheries production arises
from multiple sources. Climate model
projections of physical ocean properties (e.g., stratification) often show
similar trends on global and ocean-basin scales, but significant biases and
inter-model spread are common at regional scales. Changes in primary production obtained from
marine ecosystem models coupled to physical climate model projections exhibit a
broader range of possible outcomes.
These projections, however, often exhibit decreasing primary productivity
at low- and mid-latitudes due to global warming (which increases surface
stratification and exacerbates nutrient limitation), and increasing
productivity at high latitudes (where increasing stratification and decreasing
ice cover alleviates light limitation).
A global analysis of the transfer of primary production to mesozooplankton using observations and models suggests that
such changes in primary productivity are likely to produce disproportionate
changes in the productivity of higher trophic levels. Most notably, decreased productivity in low
latitude systems may produce even more pronounced decreases in fisheries
production. Model diagnosis suggests
that this amplification arises from 1) a shift in the size-structure of the
phytoplankton community; and 2) changes in the growth efficiency of consumers
responding to changes in food supply.
These mechanisms also contribute to the non-linear ecosystem response to
climate variability. The potential
implications of these results for the Gulf of Maine will be discussed.
Towards Understanding the Impacts of Didemnum vexillum
Judith Pederson, Greg Booma, John Davis, Chryssostomos Chryssostomidis, Ian Katz, Seth Newburg, and Michael
Soroka,
MIT Sea Grant College Program, Cambridge, MA
Non-linear interactions between fishing,
haddock egg predation and climate can drive major population cycles in Atlantic
herring
David
E. Richardson and Jon A. Hare National
Marine Fisheries Service, NOAA Narragansett, RI
Theoretical
models suggest that populations exposed to gradual changes in climate or human
pressures may abruptly shift between alternate stable states. However, there is an absence of empirical
data and well-parameterized mechanistic models supporting alternate stable
states in exploited marine fish populations.
We present a population model indicating that egg predation by haddock
can cause alternate stable population levels in Georges Bank Atlantic
herring. This population model assumes
that: (1) larval herring abundance is a function of herring spawning stock
biomass and egg survival from haddock predation, (2) that
haddock exhibit a type III functional feeding response and (3) that recruitment
is a density-dependent function (Beverton Holt) of
larval herring abundance.
Parameters for the model were
estimated using time-series of observed larval herring abundance, stock
assessment estimates of herring spawning stock biomass and recruitment, and an
index of haddock predation intensity derived from the haddock stock assessment.
The model estimated that from 1971-2005 herring egg survival rates from haddock
predation ranged from <2 to 70%. Year-to-year >90% declines in observed
larval herring abundance following the 1975 and 2003 haddock year classes were
well predicted by the model. By incorporating
estimated fishing mortality rates into this population model, we were able to
explain the population trends of Atlantic herring over the past four decades,
including a decline in the abundance of herring since 2006 in a compilation of
17 fisheries-independent time series.
Climate-associated changes in the dynamics of the herring population
were simulated by altering the asymptote of the larval abundance to recruitment
relationship. These simulated changes
altered the threshold herring population size between an increasing and
decreasing population. Even minor
changes in the environment could thus trigger abrupt changes in herring
abundance. However, herring fishing
mortality rates and haddock population levels, both of which are strongly
influenced by management decisions, remained dominant drivers of herring
population trends. Overall, these
results illustrate how predator abundance, fishing intensity, and climate can
interact in a non-linear way to drive large-amplitude low-frequency cycles in
the abundance of a small pelagic species.
Assessing the social bases of public
perceptions about marine resource use, coastal environmental problems, and
climate change in Maine
Dr.
Thomas G. Safford Department
of Sociology / Carsey Institute, University of New Hampshire
Like
many other coastal areas of the United States, Maine’s coastal communities
are experiencing dramatic social and environmental changes. Commercial fishing is in decline, marine
aquaculture is expanding,
and tourism has emerged as one of the region’s principle economic
drivers. Second home development is
expanding rapidly and shifting demographics are altering the social as well as
cultural character of many coastal towns and villages. Environmental problems, ranging from
pollution of beaches and clambeds to sea level rise
due to climate change, also threaten the social and ecological well-being of
these communities. Governmental and
non-governmental entities are grappling with how to address these
interconnected social and environmental concerns. This makes studying the social forces influencing how
coastal residents view different uses of marine resources and their
inter-relationship with both global and local environmental problems a key
research area.
In
August 2009, social scientists at the Carsey Institute at the University of New Hampshire set out to investigate
the inter-relationships between social and environmental change in coastal
communities across the United States. A pilot study was conducted in the two
easternmost “Downeast” counties in Maine, Hancock and Washington. A random-digit-dial phone survey of
approximately 1,400 residents was conducted to gauge local views about social
change and the coastal environment.
Survey results showed marked differences in how respondents perceive
alternative uses of marine resources, ocean environmental problems, and the
threat of climate change. Respondents’
level of education, county of residence, and political party affiliation
significantly predicted individual views.
Respondents were also asked about the role that science and the needs of resource users should play when
addressing marine-related concerns.
Patterns emerging from these data show distinct differences in the way
segments of the Downeast Maine population view the
use of marine resources, environmental threats, as well as the management of
the ocean environment. These results
highlight both challenges and opportunities for practitioners as they
attempt to engage communities in the management of marine resources as well as
address the human and ecological effects from climate change and other
environmental threats.
Environmental Factors Affecting the
Occurrence and Concentrations of Pathogenic Vibros in
the Great
Bay
Estuary
Steve
Jones, Cheryl Whistler and Vaughn Cooper
University of New Hampshire
The
potential effects of global warming on the incidence of shellfish-borne disease
in the Gulf of Maine (GOM) are an emerging public health concern because of
pathogenic indigenous bacteria like Vibrio vulnificus (Vv) and Vibrio parahaemolyticus (Vp). Shellfish programs are now required to monitor
environmental conditions that are conducive to vibrio
growth (water temperature above 81°F) because their occurrence and
concentrations, and the incidence of vibrio-related
disease, are significantly higher in warm water, like in the Gulf of Mexico. Because these species
are present as both virulent and non-virulent strains in estuarine
environments, there is a concern that warming water temperatures in GOM
estuaries will increase the occurrence of virulent strains and shellfish risk.
In previous studies in the Great Bay Estuary (GBE) Vv and Vp were non-detectable in oysters and water from
December to May, with an increase in incidence and concentrations during summer
before declining in the fall.
These studies established temperature and some environmental conditions as
significant factors in the incidence and concentrations of Vv and Vp, but the detection methods did
not differentiate virulent from non-virulent strains.
In
our most recent (2007-2010) studies we employed molecular methods (PCR, qPCR) to detect, enumerate, and discriminate the virulence
potential of Vv and Vp in
oysters, water and sediments in GBE. Sites included approved and prohibited
sites in GBE and the Oyster and Piscataqua rivers. Vp was detected from April into January and Vv from
June into September. Water temperature and dissolved oxygen concentration,
though not salinity or turbidity, were significantly correlated with Vp concentrations. The incidence
of Vv was much less frequent and it was detected over a shorter time period compared
to earlier (1993-95) studies. The concentrations of Vp were relatively high and persisted longer in
sediments and oysters than in water. No Vp
strains harboring clinical markers were ever detected in freshly harvested
oysters, sediments and water, although they were detected after temperature
abuse of oysters harvested in August 2009. These results confirm public health
concerns related to Vibrios and expected climate
changes in the Gulf of Maine.
Current Climate Change Research Projects
at the Great
Bay
National Estuarine Research Reserve
Steve J. Miller Great Bay National Estuarine
Research Reserve NH
The
Great Bay National Estuarine Research Reserve (GBNERR) goal is a sustainable
Great Bay Ecosystem. GBNERR does this by conducting research, developing and
implementing stewardship programs, and through education for schools, families, and
decision makers through the Coastal Training Program. GBNERR is currently
involved with several climate change research projects. These include the
Cooperative Institute for Coastal & Estuarine
Environmental Technology (CICEET) funded study Assessing the Risk of 100-year Freshwater Floods in the Lamprey River
Watershed of New Hampshire Resulting from Changes in Climate and Land Use;
the NH Charitable Foundation funded project to write a Regional Climate Assessment Report: Climate Change in the Great Bay
Watershed that will focuses on four themes—1) land conservation and stewardship, 2) water quality, 3)
habitats and biological communities, and 4) climate change impacts and
adaptation;
the NERRS Science Collaborative funded project Nitrogen Sources and Transport Pathways in the Great Bay Estuarine
Ecosystem and the Application of this Research to Reduce Nitrogen Loads in Great
Bay which has some climate change implications; and the GBNERR/NHFG project
to establish a long term monitoring program to track changes in salt marsh
vegetation as it relates to sea level rise and habitat migration. The Reserve
is also the lead agency in the formation of the NH Coastal
Adaptation Workgroup. The purpose of NHCAW is to bring together NH coastal
stakeholders with interest in or responsibilities for organizational,
municipal, or state level coastal adaption planning. Each of these projects
will be describe, including goals and objectives, projected completion dates
and how participants can receive the results of the work once completed.
Environmental Forcing of American Lobster
(Homarus americanus)
Settlement in inshore nursery grounds: Role of temperature and wind
Jaini, Mahima1; Wahle, Richard1;
Thomas, Andrew1; Lawton,
Peter2. 1University of Maine, School of
Marine Sciences, Orono, ME, 2Department
of Fisheries and Oceans, St. Andrews, NB, E5B 1A8, Canada.
Annual
surveys of American lobster (Homarus americanus) in New England and Atlantic Canada
conducted at the end of the larval settlement season, have given rise to over
20 years of data on the annual recruitment of young-of-year (YoY) lobsters to inshore cobble nursery grounds. Time series
from the oceanographically contrasting regions of Rhode Island, Midcoast
Maine and Beaver Harbour, New Brunswick reveal considerable interannual variability, suggesting the role of
environmental factors in regulating lobster larval supply and transport during
the planktonic stages of development. This is a progress report on a NASA-supported study evaluating
statistical correlations between lobster YoY
settlement and various physical environmental data sets from satellites, data
buoys and weather stations. YoY indices were
correlated with environmental indices (such as Sea Surface Temperature
anomalies (SSTa)) for the month of settlement
sampling as well as prior months when larvae hatch and are transported by ocean circulation.
To date our analysis identifies areas of the sea surface that may be
oceanographic predictors of variability in lobster larval settlement.
Subsequent analyses will investigate correlations of YoY
indices with monthly alongshore and cross-shore wind stress measures that will
be derived from buoy and island weather station daily wind data. In addition to
these analyses, we will also test the role of freshwater influx into coastal
areas in regulating lobster settlement as it may affect circulation and larval
transport. The results of this work will contribute to the application of
environmental data in a coupled biophysical model of lobster larval transport
and population connectivity.
Sustaining Quality of Place in the Saco
River
Estuary Understanding Stakeholder Roles, Values and Concerns
Christine
B. Feurt and Lindsay Kelly University of New England &
Wells National Estuarine Research Reserve
The
Saco River watershed is the
largest watershed in southern Maine, encompassing more than
1,500 square miles. The estuarine portion of the river includes a variety of
coastal habitats, including rocky intertidal, sandy beaches, mudflats and salt
marshes. Coastal development, increasing population density, changing land use
and climate change play a role in determining the ecological health and long
term sustainability of qualities of the Saco River estuary that are
important to the people who live, work and play in the region. As part of a
five year study, an interdisciplinary team of student and faculty researchers
at the University of New England working in partnership with the Wells National
Estuarine Research Reserve are interested in understanding how the physical
attributes of the watershed such as flow of pollutants and nutrients and land
use in the region interact to affect the plants and animals using the estuary.
Improving land use policy and decision-making by developing locally relevant
indicators that connect estuarine ecological health with quality of place
attributes deemed important by local stakeholders is one goal of the project.
This
paper reports results from the first
year of social science research using the Collaborative Learning approach to
develop and evaluate communication strategies that engaged researchers and
stakeholders in dialogues about ecological indicators, valued attributes of the
estuary, perceived threats and current management challenges. Employing a suite
of qualitative methods, student and faculty researchers conducted a stakeholder
assessment that identified and engaged people from more than thirty community, governmental and non-governmental organizations
in Collaborative Learning activities focusing on the Saco Estuary. The
assessment identified important qualities of place connected to ecological
health, areas of concern for sustaining the Saco and the range and scope
of an existing stewardship network actively engaged in the region. Researcher
and stakeholder interactions and community dialogues will continue to build
shared understanding and facilitate an ecosystem approach to land use decision-making
that looks holistically at economic, ecological and social factors that
interact to affect the ecological health of the estuary and locally valued
qualities of place.
Impacts of climate change on the
subarctic copepod, Calanus finmarchicus, in the Gulf
of Maine:
is it in hot water?
Jeffrey
A. Runge1,
Frederic Maps1,
Andrew Leising2, Andrew J. Pershing1, James J. Pierson3 David G. Kimmel4,
1 School of Marine Sciences,
Gulf of Maine Research Institute, University of Maine, Portland, 2 Southwest Fisheries Science Center, NOAA, Pacific Grove, CA,. 3 Horn Point Laboratory, University of Maryland
Center for Environmental Science, Cambridge,MD, 4 Institute for Coastal Science and
Policy, East Carolina University, Greenville, NC
The
planktonic copepod, Calanus finmarchicus,
resides at the southern edge of its subarctic range in the Gulf of Maine, where it is a
prominent component of the zooplankton community. It is adapted to survive
seasonal periods of low food by producing a lipid-rich, dormant preadult stage in summer, which in higher latitudes
overwinters and molts to the reproductive adult stage in time to take advantage
of the winter-spring bloom in the subsequent year. Using demographic time
series data from the Gulf of Maine and an individual-based
population dynamics model, we present the case that temperatures in the Gulf of Maine are too warm to allow C. finmarchicus to overwinter for such an extended
period. Instead, many "overwintering" individuals must, for metabolic reasons,
break out of dormancy in late summer to late fall, at which time they produce a
fall generation that contributes to sustaining the Calanus stock in the region.
We present alternate scenarios of consequences of climate change on the
regional population. One source of forcing is the alternation
between intrusion into the deep Gulf of colder Labrador Subarctic Slope Water and
warmer Atlantic Slope Water, influencing duration of dormancy. Another source
of forcing is the warming of
surface temperatures in late summer, influencing the capacity of Calanus to produce a fall generation.
Substantial reduction in abundance or disappearance of
C. finmarchicus from the
region would arguably have serious repercussions for the distribution,
condition and population numbers of forage species such as sand
lance, herring and mackerel, as well as northern right whales, that seasonally
feed heavily on lipid- rich Calanus
stages along the coastal shelf, banks and ledges of the Gulf.
Modeling copepod populations in the Gulf
of Maine: building prediction capability through a process-oriented approach
Rubao Ji1,
Cabell Davis1, Christoph Stegert1 1Biology Department, Woods Hole
Oceanographic Institution, MS #33, Redfield
2-14, Woods Hole, MA
Zooplankton are sensitive to climate change and may amplify
subtle environmental signals due to their non-linear responses to environment forcing. It is critically
important to understand the underlying biological-physical mechanisms that
control the variability of zooplankton populations, such that the predictions
on how the climate change might affect plankton and higher trophic levels
become possible. In this study, we use a
coupled hydrodynamics/food-web/population-dynamics model to identify the key processes
controlling the observed seasonality and distributional patterns of key copepod
populations in the Gulf of Maine region including Pseudocalanus spp., Centropages
typicus, and Calanus finmarchicus. The importance
of life history traits (e.g. development, reproduction, mortality, diel and seasonal migration) vs. physical processes (e.g.
advection and diffusion) will be examined. The implication of this modeling
study on data-need, observing system design, and climate change scenario
testing will also be discussed. Environmental Monitors on Lobster Trap
Project's First Decade
Environmental Monitors on Lobster Trap
Project’s First Decade
Jim
Manning, NOAA's Northeast Fisheries Science Center, Woods Hole, MA
Dozens
of New
England
lobstermen have been recording hourly bottom temperatures on their traps since
2001. The web-served data from various
fixed locations and depths around the Gulf of Maine now allow investigators to
examine processes at a variety time scales ranging from semi-diurnal to
inter-annual. Given the cost
effectiveness of the operation and the enthusiastic cooperation of the
participants, it should be possible to maintain the program and investigate
multi-year climatic scale cycles in the future.
Several
examples of processes apparently occurring at different time scales will be
described including wind-induced turnovers, lunar cycles, and the longer term
trend. The question of just how warm it has been in recent months compared to
the last 10 years, for example, can be quantified and compared to other warm
years (2002 and 2006). Efforts to use this data to
help validate numerical models will also be discussed.
Climate
change vulnerability assessments in support of management adaptation planning for the salt marshes of
Massachusetts Bays
Amanda L. Babson1, Jordan M. West1, and Jay Baker2. (1) U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency, (2) Massachusetts Bays National Estuary
Program
We present the results of a novel method for assessing
key vulnerabilities of Massachusetts Bays salt marshes
to climate change impacts, as part of EPA’s Climate Ready Estuaries Program.
The assessment used an expert elicitation approach to evaluate climate change
vulnerabilities of two key salt marsh ecosystem processes - sediment retention
and plant/bird community interactions. Expert elicitation is a process for obtaining
the judgments of experts to characterize uncertainty and fill data gaps where
traditional scientific research is not feasible or data are not yet available. For each ecosystem
process, a group of experts developed an influence diagram modeling the
relationships among key anthropogenic stressors and physical and ecological
variables that regulate marsh processes. They then characterized the type and
degree of these influences, their sensitivity to change, and the relative
importance of the influences to the ecosystem process endpoints. Some influences were identified as increasing in
importance under two future climate scenarios, while other influences increased
in sensitivity. Based on these changes, key pathways in the influence diagram,
which offer opportunities for management adaptation,
are identified. For the community
interactions group, the endpoint of concern was saltmarsh
sharp-tailed sparrow habitat. One key pathway begins with the influence of
nitrogen on the ratio of native high marsh to invasive Phragmites. This influence was characterized as increasing in importance in
the climate scenarios. This composition of grasses in turn affects marsh
elevation, which is an influence on the endpoint that was found to increase in sensitivity.
For the sediment retention group, the endpoint of concern was the balance
between accretion and erosion. The influence of marsh edge erosion on this
endpoint was identified as increasing in importance and a likely threshold
under future climate scenarios, whereby the extent of erosion could reach a
tipping point leading to rapid marsh collapse. Resulting management conclusions include: 1) focus management
priorities on influences that are well understood and become more sensitive
and/or important under future climate scenarios, 2)
recognize the ability of marshes to restore themselves under the right
conditions, and 3) conduct multi-habitat restoration.
Poster Session
Climate Change and Northern Shrimp in the
Gulf
of Maine
Anne Richards, Maureen Taylor, Northeast Fisheries Science Center, Woods Hole, MA
Jay
O’Reilly, Kimberly
Hyde, Northeast Fisheries Science Center Narragansett, RI
Northern shrimp (Pandalus borealis) in the Gulf of Maine occur primarily in
the relatively cold western portion of the Gulf. Water temperature during the
larval period appears to be important in determining recruitment strength of
northern shrimp; warmer temperatures are related to poorer early life survival.
However, despite a warming trend in nearshore shrimp nursery areas over the
past quarter century, some
of the largest shrimp yearclasses on record have been
produced in recent years. A possible explanation relates to shifts over time in
the relationship between shrimp hatch timing and timing of the phytoplankton
blooms which provide food for the shrimp larvae. Shrimp hatch timing is strongly related to
temperature while timing of the bloom in coastal areas is more strongly tied to
light. We examine these relationships and relate them to shrimp yearclass survival estimates from fishery-independent
survey data. The loose coupling between processes determining the timing of the
shrimp hatch and the evolution of their food source suggests that shrimp
recruitment may become increasingly variable under climate-induced warming of
the Gulf of Maine.
The Northern Extent of the Saco
River
Plume and Its Interaction with the Gulf
of Maine
Coastal Currents
Barbara
Fortier and Dr. Charles E. Tilburg, University of New England, Biddeford, ME
This study focuses on the buoyant, freshwater
discharge plume from the Saco River, the 6th
largest river emptying into the Gulf of Maine, with a drainage basin
of 4410 km2 and an annual average discharge rate of 77m3s-1.
River
discharge produces highly stratified, buoyant, freshwater plumes that can
extend over expansive areas and can affect transport and mixing for large distances
downstream. Biological processes in the
coastal ocean are closely coupled to the dynamics of freshwater plumes, so
understanding how they change under various conditions is important. This
study’s purpose is to determine what variables (high precipitation/discharge,
wind stress, tidal phase, and/or interaction with coastal currents) affect the
plume’s spatial extent, vertically and horizontally, specifically north of the
river mouth on the upshelf edge of the plume. This is important because the Gulf of Maine is home to many
commercially-important fisheries. Since
changes in salinity can be harmful to some marine organisms, it is likely that
changes within the plume have implications on the local environment and coastal
habitats.
To
conduct this research, data is collected once a week by manually deploying a thermosalinograph to record surface salinity and a CTD
(Conductivity, Temperature, Depth) instrument to collect subsurface data from
the University of New England research vessel Llyr. To remotely collect data, two buoys are
located north of the Saco River mouth with a Seabird 37
CT meter. Saco River discharge values are
obtained daily from the USGS gauge at Cornish, ME, and wind data is obtained
from instruments installed on NOAA buoy 44007 in Casco Bay. This data is analyzed to look for patterns and changes in
the plume under various conditions, such as tidal phase, wind stress, and river
discharge rates.
Preliminary
results indicate precipitation and winds have the greatest effect on the
plume. Higher discharge rates and
southwesterly winds thin the plume and advect it
offshore, while lower discharge and northeasterly winds deepen the plume and push
it back towards the river mouth. It is
important to understand the role that this river plume plays in the biological
processes within the coastal environment.
From Science
to Policy Making: Investigating the Use and Influence of Marine Environmental
Grey Literature
Bertrum H. MacDonald,1
Peter G. Wells,2 Suzuette S. Soomai,3
Danielle M. Cossarini,1 Ruth E. Cordes,4 and
Gregory R.G. Hutton1
1School of Information Management, Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS
2School
for Resource and
Environmental Studies and Marine Affairs Program, Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS
3
Marine Affairs Program, Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS 4 Independent
Information
Consultant, Halifax, NS
Publication
of grey literature has grown extensively because it is readily facilitated by
widely accessible digital technologies. Annually, thousands of publications are
generated worldwide often as grey literature. However, distribution and access
to these publications can be problematic, even in the presence of open access systems,
the Internet, and powerful search engines. Are the extensive resources (upwards
of $1 million per title) devoted to the production of such publications
justified? This question is particularly significant in environmental contexts
where decisions affecting the fate and future of terrestrial and marine-based
ecosystems could and should be informed by currently
available scientific information. This poster
outlines the framework and objectives of a research initiative being pursued by
the authors. Using major case studies of governmental and intergovernmental
organizations focused on marine environmental protection, the initiative is
investigating several questions including: What evidence, if any, exists to
confirm the use and influence of scientific grey literature? What characterizes
the flow and barriers of information published as grey
literature? In policy decision-making contexts are research reports published
as grey literature perceived differently than research published as papers in
scientific journals (even when grey literature may undergo similar quality
checks as journal papers)? And, how should information and publications
be designed for effective discovery and ultimately for impact? Through use of
a suite of research methodologies (citation analysis, content analysis of
public policy documents, interviews of key informants in public sector
management, and surveys), a comprehensive understanding of information and knowledge
diffusion and use in public sector settings is being developed. This research
is of importance to many environmental organizations that communicate with
audiences through grey literature.
Accessing the Gulf
of Maine's
wealth of climate change data
Christine
M. Tilburg 1, Susan Russell-Robinson 2, and Kathryn
Parlee3
1 Gulf of Maine
Council on the Marine Environment, Buxton, Maine. 2 U.S.
Department of the Interior, Reston, Virginia.
3 Environment Canada, Halifax, Nova
Scotia.
Climate
variables have been measured in the Gulf of Maine and its watershed for over one hundred years.
However, managers looking for a quick answer to
scientific questions rarely have the time to download and analyze data from the
various US and Canadian sources. Consequently, as part of the Gulf of Maine Council's Ecosystem Indicator
Partnership (ESIP), a webtool was devised that allows
users to quickly and easily look at data for air temperature,
precipitation and sea level rise alongside other ecosystem indicators. The
Indicator Reporting Tool (www2.gulfofmaine.org/esip/reporting) is the result of
several years worth of effort and user input.
Managers can locate data in the region using the mapping capabilities and build
graphs for the time periods of
interest. Snapshots such as those provided by the tool can provide critical information in a timely
fashion for those faced with making
decisions quickly and provide critical baseline information for use with adaptation efforts.
Climate Change and the Northeastern
Regional Association of Coastal Ocean Observing Systems (NERACOOS)
J.
Ru
Morrison (Executive Director, NERACOOS) and others
NERACOOS
is one of eleven regional associations in the United States charged with developing
the coastal component of the Integrated Ocean Observing System (IOOS). NERACOOS seeks 1) to lead the development,
implementation, operation, and evaluation of a sustained, regional coastal
ocean observing system for the northeast United
States and Canadian Maritime provinces, as part of the United States Integrated
Ocean Observing System (IOOS), 2) to promote the development, assessment, and
dissemination of data and data products that meet the needs of end users, and
3) to advocate through education and outreach for the regional, national,
and global ocean observing system and the application of scientific assessments
using environmental data to meet societal needs.
Climate
Change is cross-cutting problem that permeates all of NERACOOS’ themes whether
it is Coastal and Ocean Ecosystem Health, Ocean Energy Planning and Management,
Coastal Hazards Resiliency, or Maritime Operations. A summary of NERACOOS observing and modeling
systems will be presented as well as how they will be applied to climate change
issues identified by the 2010 New England-Canadian Maritime Collaboration and
Planning Initiative. This initiative
involved twelve regional organizations in a collaborative effort in part to develop a
consensus on the region’s most pressing issues and joint policy, planning and
management implementation responses as well as thoughtful and sustained
interaction among organizations.
Towards understanding climate variability
in the Gulf
of Maine
region over the past millennium
Karl
Kreutz1, Alan Wanamaker2, Douglas Introne1 1Climate
Change Institute and Department of Earth Sciences, University of Maine, Orono,
Maine 2Department of
Geological and Atmospheric Sciences, Iowa State University,
Reconstructing
and understanding the spatiotemporal patterns of late Holocene climate
variability remains a fundamental challenge in paleoclimatology,
particularly with respect to coupled ocean/atmosphere systems affecting the Arctic such as the North
Atlantic Oscillation (NAO) and Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO). Recent results from a compilation of lake
sediment and ice core data have demonstrated a long term Arctic cooling over
the past 2000 years, however significant spatial
variability exists related to regional-scale processes. In the North Atlantic, we are tackling this
problem using the long-lived
bivalve mollusk Arctica islandica, and
have demonstrated cooling in the Gulf of Maine over the past 1000
years related to coupled changes in the NAO, Labrador
current, Gulf
Stream,
and Atlantic meridional overturning circulation. We are refining this work by developing a
continuous annually dated master shell chronology spanning the last 1000 years,
and using shell growth history, geochemistry (stable isotopes, radiocarbon),
and relevant instrumental data in the Gulf of Maine to address the mechanisms
responsible for the Medieval Climate Anomaly/Little Ice Age
transition in the mid- and high-latitude Northern Hemisphere. Here we present results from a June 2010
sampling trip in the Gulf of Maine, and discuss possible
implications for understanding the impact of climate variability
on Atlantic salmon and other fisheries stocks over the past millennium.
Diadromous
Species Response to Climate Change: a literature review summarizing impacts of
climate change on diadromous fish in the Gulf
of Maine.
Barbara
S. Arter, University of Maine Diadromous Species
Restoration Research Network and Mathew Dietert,
University of Maine, Graduate Student
The
Diadromous Species Restoration Research Network is a
five-year initiative funded by the National Science Foundation to advance the
science of diadromous fish restoration and promote
state-of-the-art scientific approaches to multiple-species restoration through
workshops, conferences, web sharing, and journal publications. The Network is a
joint project of the University of Southern Maine and the University of Maine’s Senator George J. Mitchell Center for Environmental &
Watershed Research. This poster presents a literature review exploring the
impacts of climate change on diadromous species.
Historically,
diadromous fish contributed to the sustenance and
economic growth of the Atlantic states and Canadian Maritime Provinces.
However, since the industrial revolution, the tolls of environmental stress,
overfishing, and habitat loss have reduced many of these populations. Although
there is now a popular drive to remove dams in the hopes reintroducing and rehabilitating
fish runs, the most recent challenges faced by diadromous
fish is global climate change and the subsequent changes in physical habitat
and range shifts for diadromous
and competitive species.
The
impacts of climate change on a species that spends juvenile stages in
freshwater and adulthood at sea are far-reaching. For example, climate change is expected to shift
species ranges to their northern limits and to have a strong influence on
species distributions. Studies indicate
that many species lose suitable habitat and therefore shift their range when confronted
with changes in water temperature and precipitation. Winter flows are very
likely to be enhanced and summer flows reduced, thereby enhancing overwintering
conditions but reducing the amount of summer refugia. Spring,
summer, and fall low flows may also create out-migration barriers for smolts
and in-migration barriers for spawning adults. Changes in spring precipitation and flow
regime may also cause acid pulses that hinder the smoltification
process. Warmer winter conditions are projected to cause an increase in growing
season and freshwater productivity possibly resulting in a reduction in anadromy in facultative
anadromous species since there would be no need to seek productivity at sea.
Compiling
a long-term data set based on student intertidal transect surveys at
the Shoals Marine Lab, Appledore Island, ME
Meg
M. Eastwood, Kipp Quinby, and Hal Weeks Shoals Marine Lab
Long
term data describing organism distribution and abundance are valuable
in assessing changes due to any number of factors, including but not
limited to climate patterns, isolated or chronic disturbance events,
ecological interactions, and establishment of invasive species.
Establishing ecological baselines now may be critical to
understanding these changes, but long-term data sets are rare due to
the inherent difficulties involved with funding and maintaining such
projects. The Shoals Marine Laboratory (SML) has accumulated over
twenty-five years of data from student transect surveys that detail
the distribution and abundance of organisms in both exposed and
protected rocky intertidal habitats on Appledore Island in the Gulf
of Maine. SML uses the transect studies to teach research methods and
focus student observations in the field; we hope that compiling the
survey data will allow us to track and document changes around
Appledore Island and provide a long-term dataset with baseline
information to the broader scientific community. We present here a
selection of data from the much greater, ongoing collection to
illustrate its potential.